Courtroom scene depicting the legal challenges gyms like The Gym 24/7 Fitness faced during pandemic closures.
The U.S. Supreme Court has declined to hear a lawsuit from the owners of The Gym 24/7 Fitness against the state of Michigan, regarding financial losses during a COVID-19 mandated closure. The case highlighted the conflict between public health measures and business rights, as lower courts upheld the state’s actions amid the pandemic. This decision underscores ongoing legal challenges for businesses affected by COVID-19 regulations, as several lawsuits remain unresolved in state courts.
Alma, Michigan – On June 2, 2022, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear a lawsuit brought forth by owners of The Gym 24/7 Fitness against the state of Michigan. The owners, Randy Clark and Yvette Franco-Clark, sought compensation for financial losses incurred during a six-month closure mandated by Governor Gretchen Whitmer’s stay-at-home order due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
The lawsuit, filed in 2020, contended that the closure amounted to an unconstitutional taking of the owners’ property. The couple argued that their gym should be reimbursed for the financial strains the enforced shutdown imposed on their business. Their claims were initially supported by a ruling from the Michigan Court of Claims which noted that the state failed to adequately justify the necessity of the extended closure.
However, in a significant reversal, the Michigan Court of Appeals dismissed the owners’ claims, asserting that the gym was not deprived of all economically productive uses of its property. The Appeals Court further noted that the matter of regulatory takings related to COVID-19 closures had been addressed by numerous federal and state appellate courts, with each siding against such claims.
The U.S. Supreme Court’s decision to decline the case was made without any comment, leaving the Court of Appeals’ ruling intact. The Michigan Attorney General’s Office articulated that the state’s closure was justified considering the high rates of death and illness associated with COVID-19, underscoring that Michigan had recorded over 40,000 deaths linked to the virus.
This case was emblematic of a broader trend, with many gyms and fitness centers affected by similar executive orders during the pandemic. The legal argument put forth by The Gym 24/7 Fitness also included allegations from a proposed class representing varied fitness businesses challenging the state’s actions. Nonetheless, the Appeals Court determined that there was no substantial ground for claiming a regulatory taking regarding the pandemic’s closure mandates.
While the Supreme Court’s decision marked a significant hurdle for The Gym 24/7 Fitness, it does not conclude the broader legal challenges faced by businesses affected by COVID-19 regulations in Michigan. Reports indicate that various other lawsuits continue to make their way through state courts, suggesting that the fallout from pandemic-related restrictions remains a contentious legal issue.
This case and its outcome highlight the tension between public health measures and the rights of business owners. The judicial system has been tasked with balancing these competing interests, especially as economic recovery varies widely across sectors. Given the precedent set by this ruling and others involving similar claims, business owners nationwide may find themselves navigating complex legal landscapes as they seek recourse from government-imposed closures.
The U.S. Supreme Court’s refusal to engage with The Gym 24/7 Fitness case underscores the judicial challenges that business owners have encountered while grappling with pandemic-related regulations. As the legal system evolves in response to these unprecedented circumstances, the trajectory of other lawsuits will likely continue to shape the business landscape in Michigan and beyond.
News Summary The T-Rex Fest is back in Grand Rapids after a 13-year break, taking…
News Summary Sergey Nydam, a homeless man in Grand Rapids, has received a three-year federal…
News Summary Three major housing developments in the Grand Rapids area have been granted a…
News Summary A tragic accident occurred on US-131 in Grand Rapids early Wednesday morning, resulting…
News Summary A stabbing incident at a Walmart in Traverse City, Michigan, on July 26,…
News Summary The Michigan Supreme Court has ruled that Jacqueline Davis can continue her lawsuit…